| rdfs:comment
| - __NOWYSIWYG__ The Sifu Kisu page is the only one page we currently have where a title is included in the creation of the pages. This may or may not have to do with the fact that he does exist in the real world, and IMO, to use different terms for real world and Avatar world articles is inconsistent, and changes the fact we try to be as encyclopedic as possible. Not to mention the fact that Kisu himself stated he does not ask his friends to call him "Sifu Kisu" here. I think we should simply leave the page called "Kisu". IMDb refers to him as such here, and for the page on the other martial arts master on set, Sifu Manuel Rodriguez, the title is not included in the name. (I may not be able to speak here, as I made that page, though). So, thoughts? 08:23, January 13, 2013 (UTC)
|
| abstract
| - __NOWYSIWYG__ The Sifu Kisu page is the only one page we currently have where a title is included in the creation of the pages. This may or may not have to do with the fact that he does exist in the real world, and IMO, to use different terms for real world and Avatar world articles is inconsistent, and changes the fact we try to be as encyclopedic as possible. Not to mention the fact that Kisu himself stated he does not ask his friends to call him "Sifu Kisu" here. I think we should simply leave the page called "Kisu". IMDb refers to him as such here, and for the page on the other martial arts master on set, Sifu Manuel Rodriguez, the title is not included in the name. (I may not be able to speak here, as I made that page, though). So, thoughts? 08:23, January 13, 2013 (UTC) Definitely, standard practice. 08:39, January 13, 2013 (UTC) if we do remove his title, we should find his last (or first if kisu is his last - which is it?) name to add. however, i don't believe that sifu should be removed, as it is part of his title. although a doctor does not ask his friends to refer to him as such, he is still refered to as Dr. Name in official documents and the like. in addition, kisu's importance to the avatar community is as a sifu, which is another reason that title should be left as is. as for manuel rodriguez, the term sifu should be added to his page, as the reason he is important is also because of his status as a sifu. Intelligence4 (wall • contribs) Why? Fire Lord Ozai was almost constantly referred to as such, yet we don't include the title here. Pupil Sangok was even titled that on the nick site, yet we don't use the name here. Master Pakku (a title comparible to Sifu Kisu) is simply listed as Pakku, so why should we do the same here? Because he's real? That means we aren't being encyclopedic, then. Similarly, on wikipedia, they refer to Dr. Phil as his real name, Phil McGraw. I would include Kisu's real name, however I don't know what it is, and could not find it after much searching. So, I feel Kisu will do best for now. 00:56, January 14, 2013 (UTC) ...you forget he was credited as such. I think we should stick to Sifu Kisu. It is more well known... 01:06, January 14, 2013 (UTC) The credits don't serve as a reason for why we should not stay consistent in omitting titles. I support renaming the page to "Kisu", it is more neutral. 01:21, January 14, 2013 (UTC) I completely agree with this proposal. 00:21, January 16, 2013 (UTC)
|
![[RDF Data]](/fct/images/sw-rdf-blue.png)