| Text
| - Good luck!
- If there are any neutral voters, then they should change there votes. If it some how comes out even again then it should go to the one posted first, but only after having the same support/oppose/neutral should it just go defacto to the top one. Mathmatically it most likely won't happen, but there is still a small remote chance it could, so I just picked what someone in an incredibly tight situation would pick. We should just have a set day to change the fights as well, so anyone have a good date?
- Eh, it always makes in confusing as to witch date it will be changed, we should just get a set day of the week and think of an overiding system.
- I just don't want to pressure people into voting. I think that works out well, just as a fail-safe.
- Do not remove that new guy Twilightwizard's votes or suggestion. He put them up before you made the rule.
- Twilightwizard0309, this new rule does not go into place until next week. So you have until Monday to gather 48 more mainspace edits. If you are truly determined to vote next week, you should have no problem reaching 50 by Monday. And yes mainspace edits are just normal pages. Examples are Link, Princess Zelda, Ganondorf, Tingle, Hyrule and basically every other page like that; There is a lot.
- Here is a suggestion that could help prevent messes in the suggestion page. How about a user can only post one contest a week so that we don't have one or two people placing 3 or 4 contests, rapidly filling the 8 contest limit?
- As soon as he finds out he needs 50 edits, he will do it in about 20 minutes.
- This week, we've come really close to having a tie, and starting a new ToC fight. We should figure something out, that would prevent it from actually happening, and not keep on not worring that it won't even out.
- I don't think reverted edits are subtracted from your total. Still, it'd help if you DIDN'T make edits that are reversible, or however you conjugate that one.
- Making a rule like that for a minority of users... yeah, sorry, but not only doesn't it make sense, it would set a dangerous precedent. What if someone's offended by all the Tingle hate? Shouldn't they then, by the same token, have a No-Tingle Fights rule set in place? You're just going to have to deal with it.
- Actually IP's cannot be read if the user has an account. Second I know this seems like a hassle but as AK said, this is only for the suggestions page. So if you want to participate here, just make 50 mainspace edits. Its really not that hard. Sorry for the dilemma
- people are deleting my comments, rejections, supports, and suggestions on this page.
- I can see that, but there is no rule on how good the edits have to be, so whatever.
- I've been thinking about this: if you suggest a fight, should you really be allowed to vote on other fights? I mean, almost everyone here is a good sport and will vote impartially, but still. What do you think?
- well if any conclusion is going to be reached, it needs to be soon, because it is almost time for next weeks to be made.
|
| abstract
| - Is it ok to delete a suggestion if it goes against the "Only 8 suggestions per week" rule? Xykeb Zraliv 14:08, 5 August 2008 (UTC) So... once a fight is picked... the others are just dumped into the archive? Isn't that wasteful? Couldn't the second and third best get rolled over to the next week or something?--Mjr162006 13:21, 20 October 2008 (UTC) Now that I have thought about, I'm not sure that would ever work out.--Mjr162006 13:28, 20 October 2008 (UTC) hello. just posting that when it turned to gibberish that on time;that was me. sorry-DekutullaZM 4:06 PM, 13 December 2008 (UTC) Why in the name of Volvagia is the current fight not posted? Did some vandal go through and erase everything on the page? Bek The Conqueror 23:56, 19 December 2008 (UTC) Huh? Zant's Hand vs. Wallmaster won last week's suggestion vote and is now on the ToC main page. Each time something wins, all suggestions are archived. Or they're SUPPOSED to be anyway. Seems like whoever did it this week messed up and forgot it. --AuronKaizerTalk loud, hit harder! 14:40, 20 December 2008 (UTC)
|
![[RDF Data]](/fct/images/sw-rdf-blue.png)