Phoebe is serving on a jury in a murder trial. The defendant, Stan Provazolli, claims to have had a premonition, and so led the police to his ex-wife's body. Phoebe believes that Stan is guilty; but she handles the murder weapon and has a premonition of her own, showing another man to be the murderer. In the jury room, she stalls and calls for Leo, so she can alert her sisters. Paige invites her best friend Glen to stay in the manor.