After Ethan Thomas and Rosa Angel conclude that the Torturer is next on SKX's list, they set out to find him. The two discover that Samuel Tibbits, a former teacher at St. Joseph's School, has gone missing after going to the police with information on the Torturer, who is revealed to be one of his former students. Ethan and Rosa head to the school, where they believe Tibbits and the Torturer are located.