Alexopoulous took part in NCW Femmes Fatales' first show on September 5, 2009 as a heel under the name She Nay Nay, and was defeated by Addy Starr. She picked up her first win on February 6, 2010 against Karen Brooks, while being managed by former wrestler 21st Century Fox. She Nay Nay, however, was defeated by Mistress Belmont at Volume IV and again defeated by Cheerleader Melissa at Volume V in a triple threat match that also included Mary Lee Rose, but she would pick up victories over Xandra Bale at Volume VII and Rhia O'Reilly at Volume VIII. At Volume IX on July 7, 2012, She Nay Nay lost to Pink Flash Kira.