Sam, Dan, Jeff and Patrick become concerned with Sarah's taste in men and decide to look for a guy they think is right for her. After unsuccessful solicitation with Sarah's pictures in what turned out to be a gay bar, Sam, Dan, Jeff and Patrick gets a man named Trip (played by Josh Ruben) to come to the office and court Sarah after witnessing his "remarkable" card trick. Meanwhile, Ricky assigns Jake to work with Amir about Ricky himself , and Streeter becomes a goth upon receiving the news of his parent's apparent divorce from his mother's changed relationship status on Facebook. Jake and Amir's work session immediately goes downhill as Amir starts calling 911 and Dominoes for a meal.