The Cave of Betrayal is a cave dungeon far to the east of Casabranca. In order to progress through the cave, it is necessary to have at least two people as there are barriers and gates that can't be traversed alone. The cave's magic separates travellers soon after they enter, torments them with monsters disguised as their fellow travellers, then, without warning, brings them together. Most groups then kill each other out of paranoia. The hero, Meena and Maya enter this cave in hopes of finding out what happened to Hank Hoffman, Jr. as much as to find the treasure in the cave.