Michelle was captain alongside Natalie of their high school cheerleading team: The Spirit Squad. Michelle while driving Natalie's car one fateful night decided to turn the headlights off and wait for the first car to flash them like the old Urban Legend. One unfortunate car did and Michelle soon sped after the man flashing her headlights at him. However this blinded the poor youth causing him to speed of the road and crash killing himself. Michelle and Natalie were both charged with Reckless Endangerment. Michelle is seen in an old yearbook cheerleading photo along with Natalie.