It is nearly impossible to define the overall sound to Just Another Outtakes Album...NOT!!!, because the songs in it have almost no similarities among each other. Some might call it an "outtakes album", but the band clearly thinks otherwise, as evidenced by the albums title. Guitarist David Poole says, "The best way to describe this album is through this comparison: Self-Titled to Just Another Outtakes Album...NOT!!! as Toxicity is to Steal This Album!. In layman terms, the songs on Just Another Outtakes Album...NOT!!! are just as good as the ones on Self-Titled, but the songs on the latter didnt fit on the former album."