Hoping to make Earl feel better, his brother Randy picked #205 off the list, because to Randy, mistletoe sounds Christmas-y. A few years ago, Earl caused a stripper named Mistletoe who works at Club Chubby, to fall off the stage while fooling around with Randy's laser pointer, leaving her needing to wear a brace for two years. Earl doesn't apologize, and Randy reminds him that he usually uses his nice guy voice when he talks to people on the List. Earl doesn't want Mistletoe to choose what he's going to do to make things up to her while she's pissed off at him. Still, she wants him to feel the humiliation of being laughed at on stage. Earl dons short shorts and tassels to do a shift at Club Chubby("Bad Earl") and so, Earl did cross Mistletoe off his list before he left.