No, The one that give that scar was buggy ^ - If you give an answer, give the right one -_- No the one who did it was Luffy himself. As seen in the first chapter, chapter 1, he cuts his cheek to show his courage towards Shanks and the others. agreed with the one above this text and replie for the first one...LOL BUGGY GIVE LUFFY A SCRATCH. LUFFY CAN BEAT BUGGY UP ANYDAY!