Pauly was born in Hyrule but due to taxes problems he had to leave the place and move to Mushroom Kingdom. During his childhood Pauly always visited Freddy Fazbear's Pizza and he wanted to work as delivery guy. One day, his dreams come true when he was hired by Stu Pickles to work in the restaurant as delivery guy. Pauly developed a high knowledge about video games and started to play Mario games until he became a professional in Nintendo games. Pauly was not present when The Missing Children Incident happened but he knew who was the killer when Stu told everything about what happened that day.