Our Favorite Things is performed in New York street, on the front steps of the Public Library, and stars Bert, Cookie Monster, and Oscar the Grouch. The show was originally performed outside Louis' Pizza and Union City News Agency. Bert, Cookie and Oscar have all come together to talk about their favorite things, but none of them can agree on who will go first. After singing brief portions of "C is for Cookie" and "I Love Trash", the three decide to cooperate, as they sing "Pigeons and Cookies and Trash".