When a Stranger Returns Is an American Psychological Horror Film and the sequel to the 2006 horror remake, When A Stranger Calls. Starring Amber Heard, Thomas Flanagan, Emma Roberts, Sean Faris, Cam Gigandet, Danielle Panabaker, Chelan Simmons, Crystal Lowe, Matt Lanter, Courteney Cox, Dylan McDermott, Addy Miller, Mason Cook And Shenae Grimes.