Late one night in Scourge Bay, Captain Plunder, with Filch and Simpson in tow, is attempting to gather some new crew members for his next hunt, with the aid of a supposedly ancient treasure map. Unfortunately, the ink is still wet, and the man Plunder tries to talk into joining him recognises the pirate as the biggest foul-up on the seven seas. When Simpson is called up to 'convince' the man with a big stick, Simpson only ends up clobbering Plunder, much to his immense displeasure. Just as Plunder is about to kill Simpson, he is interrupted by Queen Zorabel, who has got wind of his crew gathering attempt and wants to let her daughters go with him. They find Zorabel's daughters in Scourge Bay's roughest tavern doing what they do best: causing bother in a one-sided brawl.