MacLeod emerged in 1862, and due to Samuel's report, MacLeod was replaced on the Active roster. Samuel maintained a cover as a mercantile, and was skilled as both a book keeper and a fiddler. His mentor among the Watchers was Edgar Sanford. His name has also been recorded as Buckner. He observed the following Immortals during his life: George Geddis - 1864 to 1869. Clifford Holden - 1870 to 1879. Duncan MacLeod - 1882 to 1893. Edwina Solomon - 1893 to 1896. In the year 1896 he retired.