The issue starts in the Manor, with Paige and Leo continuing the conversation about Neena's status as "The First Witch". Leo explains that Neena, as she's calling herself now, was born before names. Paige asks what she's doing now, and Leo answers, "I wish I knew" as Neena's demon army is seen attacking the Elders. Rennek, the Darklighter, tells Neena that the demons aren't strong enough to defeat the Elders, and she responds that they won't realize that until it's too late. Back in the Manor, Leo continues telling Neena's story, explaining to Phoebe — who has retrieved the Book of Shadows — that the sisters need to know Neena's history before they attempt to confront her. Leo assures them that Neena wouldn't have killed Piper, so Piper is likely safe for now.