Garcia spent three years on Showtime's Dexter as Jamie Batista, for which she was nominated for a SAG Award for Best Ensemble in Dramatic Television Series. In 2014, she played Dr. Jae Kim in MGM's reboot film, RoboCop. Recently, she joined the cast of Fox's Lucifer in season 2, as forensic scientist Ella Lopez. In Supernatural, she portrayed secretary Nancy Fitzgerald in season 3 episode "Jus In Bello".