Sally was disappointed of Billy's loyalty when he returned to the movie with three women. After Billy, Phoebe and Piper entered the movie, Prue was attacked by a Film Geek while the others fought the Demon of Illusion; Sally Mae helped out with a tree branch. When the movie She and Billy were seen again one year later when Phoebe was watching the movie before Cole showed up in it. Two years later, Phoebe lost her hearing and tested it by watching the movie; only Sally Mae appeared this time.