He started out in one of Darth Baker's kitchen cabinets next to other Siths-to be, Darth Yeast and Darth Slice. After the success of Darth Yeast, Baker decided to yet make another Sith Lord made of food. Baker took Peanut from the cabinet, spread him on a piece of toast and added a sprinkle of EVIL. However, due to the fact that Baker couldn't resist eating Darth Peanut, it took several attempts to create the evil peanut Sith that would last longer than 24 seconds.