Kristine was one of the contestants that made it through the Right to Stay. In the partner selection, she and Max wanted to be each other's partners, which they did by Cealey and Alex. They picked Lilly and Aric to be the next team. They narrowly beat out Taylor and Isaac for the Orange spot, thus becoming the Orange Team. In Hot Potato, they lost the challenge, and overheard Dakota's plan of switching the Blue and Gray Teams.