Badass, cool, sort of evil--but with his own morals. Shelly was a great secondary "villain" in 2-4, and the fact that he's the lowest-appearing character from this case on this list (other than the dead people) just tells you how awesome 2-4 is. He made you genuinely fear for Maya's life in a way that 3-5 didn't, he had a nifty theme song, and because of him you cross-examined a radio. What's not to like? ...er. I just realized I have Shelly on this list twice. Whoops. That's not good. Is there somebody I'm missing? Otherwise, just move everybody a spot up.