NC: Hello I'm the Nostalgia Critic, I remember it so you don't have to. Of all the poorly animated, poorly written and just downright poor animated shows that came out of the 1980s...this was one of 'em. The Super Mario Bros. Super Show. NC: Now I know what you're thinking. How can a show based off two Italian plumbers in a land of mushrooms who spit fire from flowers and spend most of their time kicking turtle shells POSSIBLY be strange? NC: The short answer is, they don't. The long answer? Well, let's take a look. Mario: Hey paisanos, it's the Super Mario Bros. Super Show! NC: ...HAH! NC: Why?