Charlie had told Alan not get involved as it would only cause further hate and discontent between Alan and Judith and ruin Milly's life. Sadly' Milly's not viewed as cute. Judith has also hinted that she thinks Alan is the father, although she does not want Herb to find out. She appears with Walden in season 9 in a dream and he says she looks like Alan. In this dream, Herb kills Alan after taking a home DNA test and finding out that the father was Alan.