Jeffery is an Anything Muppet boy who appeared in a Sesame Street insert from the late 1970s. (EKA: Episode 1241) He's seen running away from a monster, trying to hide. Olivia think he's afraid of the monster and assures him they're not scary. She tells him a story about a group of monsters in the city, whom the civilians were scared of. One little girl gets the courage to approach them and is discovers they're actually nice. Back in reality, Jeffery is tagged out by a monster, with whom he was playing hide-and-seek with.