She was spending the night at Lily's and they were playing Truth or Dare. When it was Lily's turn, she dared her to say "Bloody Mary" three times in the bathroom. Lily does not think anything would happen. When Lily goes to the bathroom, she follows her and waits outside. After Lily was down she started to knock on door really hard. When she came out Lily was a little angry at them. After that, Lily's dad showed up and told them to quiet down. Soon after, Lily's dad was killed by Bloody Mary.