Detective Wylie was the detective assigned to the murder case of Bobby Parezi. Although it was Alycia Barnett that killed Bobby, Wylie was convinced that Peter was responsible and pursued him until he caught him, despite Peter disappearing for a time at Willowbridge and being held hostage by Kimberly Shaw. Wylie tried to pressure Amanda into testifying against Peter, but she decided to marry him in jail to prevent that from happening instead.