After saving Piper from Oroya Fever and breaking the rules set forth by the Elders stating he could not heal her because she was not attacked by demons his wings were clipped, and the Elders made him human. Piper then hired Leo at her club because she felt it was the least she could do for him. In 2001, Piper finds the card at P3 after Leo is taken away from her by the Elders after they attempt to marry using a Handfasting ritual. She then remembers everything they shared and demands that the Elders return Leo to her.