The video was filmed in Los Angeles in mid-April 2004. It quickly became a fan favourite. The video starts out with a television commercial starring Amy Lee's character, as she is wearing a blonde wig and a dress along with make up. She pulls a fresh pizza out of the oven and sets it on the dining room table where the rest of the "family" has gathered. The mother asks if she made it all by herself. Lying, Amy's character thinks "Oops!" to herself as the family is proud of her. She then holds the pizza box in front of the camera whiling smiling and says "There is nothing better than a good Lie".