The Makeover Fairy first appeared in the Nostalgia Chick Grease review, to grant a wish Lindsay Ellis made for Nella to receive a makeover. She later tried to help convert Dark Nella back to the good side, since Dark Nella put a paper bag on her head. First, she assisted with a seance, then, she joined the Newsies-style dance number. After Dark Nella exploded, the Makeover Fairy briefly joined Lindsay in mourning the apparent loss of the real Nella.