In "Forever Knight: A comparison of two virtual continuations", Amelia Schaffer compares and contrasts the two virtual seasons that have been written for Forever Knight: V4S and FK4. The essay includes the following descriptive comments: Schaffer also discusses the strengths and weaknesses of each of the series, criticizing FK4 for not providing "a satisfactory ending to the series", and praising V4S for "setting up an ending that, within the context of the series, seems to make more sense".