When the Host Club finally go to the beach, the twins come up with a game after some minor scuffles. The game is to discover Haruhi's biggest fear? The Host Club pulls off various tricks and experiences to see who can figure out what scares Haruhi, with her middle school photos as the prize. However, whatever they try, nothing scares Haruhi. In the midst of the game, Haruhi tries to protect some of their guests who are approached by strangers at the top of the cat rock. The strangers proceed to shove her off into the ocean, but Tamaki gets there in time and leaps after to save her. After her resuce, Haruhi responds nonchalantly that she's fine, sending Tamaki into a rage wherein he scolds her stupidity in not asking for help. The two end their encounter in a feud with Tamaki seen glancing