At the start of the game, Samantha is friends with Phoebe Adams, the High Good Witch of Belladonna Cove. She has so much of a good relationship with Phoebe, that she can become a good witch. She can do this by inviting over her magical friend, and using the interaction, "Teach Me the Ways of Light". The player is suggested to do this, because clear evidence shows reagents, both good and bad, are dominating the shelves in the house. If you look closely on the desks, you will notice Crystallized Moonbeams on Samantha's bedroom desk, and Viper's Essence on Kimberly's.