Susie (voiced by Cree Summer) is in the hospital to have her tonsils removed. When she is put under anesthesia, she has a dream that she goes to "Lots O Tots Land". There, her sister Alisa (Kath Soucie) is the good witch, Angelica (Cheryl Chase) is the wicked witch, and Susie's slippers aren't ruby ones, but they are pink and fluffy. She travels down to Hopscotch Road to meet the Magic Lizard (Tara Strong) in hopes that he will help her find her mommy (Cheryl Carter). Along the way, Susie meets up with the other Rugrats: Tommy (EG Daily) is The Scarecrow, who's looking for his screwdriver and has straw in his diapers. Phil (Kath Soucie) and Lil (Kath Soucie) (who are in a trash can) are The Tin Woodsmen and Chuckie (Christine Cavanaugh) is The Cowardly Lion.