Scott Smith was an attempted victim of Arthur Mitchell, who he captured in an arcade. While at first Scott seems to fear Arthur and is resistant to him, he eventually feels sympathy for Arthur after he (Arthur) tells him (Scott) the story of his sister, Vera Mitchell. Arthur then drugs Scott, and attempts to bury him alive in cement, but is saved by Dexter Morgan. Later, he is seen being interviewed by Debra Morgan, where he recalls how Arthur kidnapped and drugged him.