Marge is mad Homer had three girlfriends before her, and several others, but the first three were more significant than all the others. Homer tries to prove what really happened but alas, Marge left him for the night. Homer tells his family the story of his third girlfriend, who later came over to the surprise of many and then told the others about the story of his fourth girlfriend, who had once eaten too many donuts that even Homer was jealous of her eating prowess, but then he had left his fourth for a fifth girlfriend named Garlicigrazianolina Favabeans. He got his sixth girlfriend named Wendy Deodorant who had died of his fifth girlfriend's massive fart smell. Young Marge Bouvier comforted Homer of his girlfriend's death and all of his subsequent break-ups. They share a quick but pass