Summary: On a Halloween night, Numbuh 4 thinks that the Halloween is stupid. Numbuh 2 bets him that he can't get more candy than the others, so Numbuh 4 fights with Stickybeard to get the candy he needs. Eventually, Numbuh 4 steals all of his candy, making him win the bet. * Villain Debuts: Dumb John Silver * Starring: Sector V, Stickybeard and Candy Pirates * Locations: Sector V Treehouse and Sweet Revenge