Kassebaum joined the Broadway production of Wicked as Glinda on January 9th, 2007. She had her final performance with the Broadway company on October 7th, 2007, along with Julia Murney who had played Elphaba with Kassebaum on tour. They were replaced by Annaleigh Ashford and Stephanie J, Block. Kendra then returned to the role of Glinda on May 13, 2008, again with the Broadway company alongside original London standby Kerry Ellis as Elphaba. Kendra's final performance was on November 9, 2008.