After receiving Barnabas's orders, Philip enters the Chosen Room and steals the Leviathan Box. Before he can escape the antique shop, Jeb shows up and stops him. Jeb realizes he is taking the box to Barnabas. As he is about to attack him, there is a knock on the door. To Philip's relief it's an inspector named Lawrence Guthrie, who arrived in Collinsport to investigate the murders of Davenport and Paul. Lawrence and Jeb appear very suspicious of each other. Once Lawrence leaves, Jeb tells Philip he has decided not to kill him, but if he decides to betray him, Megan will suffer the consequences.