The quest diverges based on the gang you most recently joined: Black Arm Gang= * If you joined the Phoenix Gang most recently, talk to Charlie the Tramp near the south Varrock gate. (Costs 2 Zemomarks) * Replay: Skip this step if you have already completed the task to join both gangs * Speak to Katrine in the Black Arm Gang Hideout. * Talk to Jonny the Beard in the Blue Moon Inn. * Talk again and defeat Jonny the Beard. * If he disappears when you start fighting him, be sure to have auto retaliate on. You can reset the fight by walking upstairs and talking to him again. * Take the black arm to Katrine * Join the Black Arm Gang. * Talk to Moira in the back room until you get the documents.