The gang must stay on campus over spring break when the trip to Yosemite is cancelled. Stacey is waiting at PCA for her parents to pick her up to go skiing but they are four days late. Dean Rivers' golf trophy gets smashed and he assumes it was Michael and Logan so he puts them under dorm arrest. Zoey and the girls set out to find the real culprit, who turns out to be the groundsman Seamus Finnigan, a former classmate and fellow golf player of Dean Rivers who believes that Dean Rivers stole the trophy.