The Wine of Forgiveness is the second item you must retrieve for the T.O.B.Y. side quest in Fable II. Follow the golden trail to a house with the item on the upper floor in the wardrobe nearest to the bed. Toby Trotter claims that it is a sacred item he can use in a ritual to cleanse Bloodstone of its seedy, sinful ways, apparently influenced by an evil gang called The Silver Serpent, but in reality, Toby is a con man, and this is merely an expensive bottle of wine he plans to drink.