Biff and his family boarded a shuttle bus on the planet Midnight to see the scenery. The passengers heard a knocking sound from outside the shuttle. Biff became insistent that the Tenth Doctor be thrown out because he supported the entity which had possessed Sky Silvestry. He later tried to drag the Doctor out, but all of their lives were spared when the Hostess dragged the entity out to their dooms. (TV: Midnight)