After moving from a crib to a "big boy" bed, Chuckie becomes afraid when he realizes he is no longer as protected as he once was. Despite this, Chuckie attempts to settle in, but finds that there is something unsettled underneath his bed who continually scares him. Angelica reinforces his fear, as she tells him the story of Barnaby Jones, another kid a few streets over who was eaten by a supposed monster under his bed after the monster tricked him with a promise of cake and ice cream.