Unlike the other talismans, no one was able to discover the Cup of Wonder. Eventually it was the Avatar who discovered how to get the Cup by receiving three visions of the Cup in an incense-induced trance. The Avatar used the mantra gained in these visions to determine the location, and then played a special tune taught by the Exile Eyesnack on a flute, and the Cup appeared. It was later cast into the lava of the Abyss to banish to Slasher of Veils.