Lisa Toller was Joshua Leonard's girlfriend at the time of his disappearance. He vanished in the Black Hills Forest in October of 1994 while filming a documentary with Heather Donahue and Michael Williams. Lisa had only ever met Heather once before, but had an instinctual feeling that she was bad news. Lisa and Josh fought the night before he left for the project. In early 1999, Lisa was interviewed for the documentary Curse of the Blair Witch to talk about Josh.