Robert Englund as Erik Destler/The Phantom of the Opera Jill Schoelen as Christine Day Alex Hyde-White as Richard Dutton Bill Nighy as Martin Barton Stephanie Lawrence as Carlotta Terence Harvey as Inspector Hawkins Molly Shannon as Meg (New York) Emma Rawson as Meg (London) Nathan Lewis as Davies Peter Clapham as Harrison Yehuda Efroni as The Rat Catcher Terence Beesley as Joseph Buquet Mark Ryan as Mott